The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women
by Valerie Young · 2011
The book that turned 'impostor syndrome' from a vague feeling into a named, fixable pattern.
Worth reading? The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women is the definitive impostor syndrome book, not the trendiest one, the one that actually built the field. Young's competence types (the Natural Genius, the Superwoman, the Soloist) are the most useful diagnostic tool in the genre, better than Mindset or Presence for this specific problem because it's built entirely around it. Skip it if you want something breezier; this is closer to a workbook than a quick read.
| Full Title | The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women: Why Capable People Suffer from the Impostor Syndrome and How to Thrive in Spite of It |
|---|---|
| Author | Valerie Young |
| Published | 2011 |
| Publisher | Crown Business |
| Category | Self-Improvement & Psychology |
| Favorite quote | “Even though your achievements clearly emanate from you, you feel oddly disconnected from them.” |
The Verdict
Young didn’t just write about impostor syndrome, she’s the researcher who helped define it as a named, structured pattern instead of a vague feeling people apologized for having. That’s why this book holds up better than the lighter, more anecdotal takes that followed it.
The competence types are the real value here: knowing you’re specifically a Natural Genius (who panics at first struggle) or a Soloist (who reads asking for help as failure) is more useful than being told to “just be confident.” Skip it if you want something breezier; this reads more like a diagnostic workbook than a pep talk, and that’s exactly why it works.
you're competent, credentialed, and still convinced you're one mistake from being found out
you want a quick pep talk instead of a structured, research-backed breakdown of the pattern
Book Summary
Impostor syndrome isn't a confidence problem, it's a mismatch between how you define competence and how competence actually works. Young identifies distinct types (the Perfectionist, the Superwoman, the Natural Genius, the Soloist, the Expert) so you can name your specific flavor instead of treating it as one generic feeling. The mismatch is often about unrealistic definitions: believing real experts never feel doubt, never need help, or always know the answer immediately. Once you see those definitions as the actual bug, not your ability, the fix becomes tractable. Young argues the condition is disproportionately common among high-achieving women and minorities because of how competence gets signaled and rewarded differently across groups, so the fix isn't just individual mindset work, it includes recognizing the systemic pattern.
Top 10 Lessons from The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women
- Impostor syndrome is a mismatch between your definition of competence and how competence actually works, not a lack of ability.
- There are distinct competence types: the Perfectionist, the Superwoman, the Natural Genius, the Soloist, the Expert.
- The Natural Genius type believes real competence means getting it right immediately, without struggle.
- The Soloist type believes asking for help is proof you don't belong.
- The Expert type believes they must know everything before they can speak up or apply.
- Real experts feel doubt regularly; doubt is not evidence you're a fraud.
- Redefining competence to include struggle and asking questions removes the trap, not just 'building confidence.'
- Impostor feelings show up more in groups that get less consistent positive feedback on their competence.
- Talking openly about the feeling with peers reduces its power because it breaks the illusion you're the only one.
- Taking credit for your work out loud is a practiced skill, not a personality trait you either have or don't.
Top 4 Quotes from The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women
"Even though your achievements clearly emanate from you, you feel oddly disconnected from them."
Valerie Young, The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women
"Research has found that people are more likely to attribute a man's success to ability and yours to luck."
Valerie Young, The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women
"You can have all the confidence in the world and still be reluctant to self-promote out of a steadfast belief that a person's work should speak for itself."
Valerie Young, The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women
"Partly this has to do with the tendency for females to blame failure on a lack of ability. Males do just the opposite. They credit themselves for their accomplishments and point to outside reasons for failure."
Valerie Young, The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women worth reading?
Yes, if you're accomplished and still feel like a fraud waiting to be exposed. It's the book that named and structured impostor syndrome, not a lighter derivative of it.
What is the main idea of The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women?
Impostor syndrome comes from an unrealistic definition of competence, not a real skills gap. Young breaks it into named types (Natural Genius, Superwoman, Soloist, Expert, Perfectionist) so you can target your specific pattern.
Who should read The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women?
Competent, credentialed people, especially women, who feel like frauds despite real accomplishments and want a structured explanation, not just a pep talk.
Is this book only for women?
It's written specifically about and for women's experience of the pattern, including how it shows up differently across groups, but the competence-type framework applies to anyone with impostor feelings.
Ready to read it?
Get The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women on Amazon
